This bear market, too, shall pass.
But then what?
Eventually, severe stock market declines end. And the current bear
market, regardless of when it finally runs its course, also will end.
That could mean handsome returns for investors who happen to catch the
bottom of the downturn.
Starting with the stock market crash that preceded the Depression,
U.S. stock markets have suffered nine bear markets that lasted at least
one year. Those were the bears of 1929-32, 1937-38, 1938-42, 1946-49,
1968-70, 1973-74, 1976-78, 1981-82 and the current nose-dive that began
in early 2000.
But once the bears had been chased away from the stock markets,
investors danced in the streets during the period immediately following
the first eight of those downturns.
The average return during the 12 months after those bear markets had
run their course, as measured by the value of the S&P 500 index, was 59
percent. The biggest 12-month gain -- a jump of 171 percent -- came
following the 1929-32 crash. The smallest gain was a 10 percent advance
after the 1976-78 bear market. The other one-year gains for the S&P
ranged from 34 percent to 61 percent, according to a Times analysis of
Bloomberg data.
The big problem is that it's not easy for individual investors to
take advantage of those gains.
"The strategy would normally be to take every last dollar you've got
and buy," said Gerald Perritt, president of Perritt Capital Management
in Chicago. "But that's impossible for a lot of us."
Then there's the complication associated with bear markets and
recessions. An estimated 77 percent of the bear markets since 1900
coincided with or were followed by a recession, according to a history
of the stock market compiled by Jack Schannep of TimingIndicator.com. So
that means around the time a bear market is ending, people often don't
have much spare cash to invest in stocks. A lot of people don't even
have jobs.
"That's the paradox of bear markets," Perritt said. "The best time to
buy is when people generally can't buy."
Some economists caution that people shouldn't necessarily expect to
make back their money all at once, even if they manage to jump back into
stocks near the trough of the bear.
"A rising market is generally a much slower process than a falling
market," said Alex Cassuto, a professor of economics at Cal State
Hayward. "With markets, you have something we call kurtosis, which means
there aren't equal percent changes before and after the tops and bottoms
of a market."
But market watchers warn that this time around, any rebound could be
muted. In part, that's because the bear market was unleashed and then
prolonged by a series of negative events for the market.
First off, the federal government pursued Microsoft Corp. in an
anti-trust case, and the Internet bubble imploded. Then came the onset
of the recession. Things quickly worsened with the terrorist attacks on
the East Coast, which triggered thousands of layoffs and devastated the
airline and tourism industries. Earlier this year, corporate fraud
scandals roiled the markets again. Finally, investors are fearful about
the pace of the economic recovery and the possibility of a war with
Iraq.
"There are a lot of big trees in that forest, and they have all come
down about the same time," Perritt said.
This means investors will be extraordinarily cautious about jumping
back into stocks.
"Every time the market starts to head higher, a lot of people will
take that opportunity to sell their stocks and redeem themselves out of
this market," said Charles Geisst, a stock market historian and author
of the 2002 book "Wheels of Fortune."
Investors will have to believe that much of the murky outlook for the
stock market has been cleared away before they feel confident about
returning in a big way.
"These exogenous events, such as a war with Iraq, have to disappear,"
Geisst said. "The lack of resolution with Iraq is more uncertainty than
the market can handle."
Corporate profits could be another drag on the rebound. Normally,
corporate profits improve quickly and are an early indicator of a market
recovery. This time, it could take a bit longer for corporate profits to
visibly improve, said Xiao-Jun Zhang, a professor of accounting at UC
Berkeley's Haas School of Business.
"Because of the impact from the corporate scandals, the financial
managers at companies really want to be conservative in reporting
profits," Zhang said. "Anything they are not sure about, they will book
as an expense."
This time around, corporate profits could actually become a lagging
indictor. Zhang believes it might not be a bad idea to see whether
companies' revenues are beating expectations.
Either way, a rising market, whenever that happens to resume, could
begin suddenly, said Norm Loofbourrow, a San Ramon-based investment
adviser with American Investors Co. in San Ramon. Investors who aren't
savvy or nimble could miss out on the upturn.
"Most of the money in the market is managed by professionals and
large pension funds, and they will start to move in first when there's a
rebound," Loofbourrow said. "Then, it will be months later when the rest
of the herd moves in."